I haven’t been to either Ireland or Northern Ireland, and I would love to go. My ancestors were most likely ethnic Scottish Protestants who lived and squabbled with each other on various sides of the Scottish/English/Irish border, and eventually made their way through Northern Ireland and then to Philadelphia, where they were not warmly welcomed by the famously tolerant Quakers and fanned out into the hills and foothills to the west, where they were understandably not warmly welcomed by the Native Americans who already lived there. Despite tales that white-nationalist, self-labeled “hillbilly” politicians here in the USA try to tell themselves, most of us don’t feel much if any connection to the old country. (In the Virginia foothills I am originally from, I don’t recall ever hearing the word “hillbilly”. “White trash” was the term of art, and not a pejorative but a self-chosen label that described our position on the social ladder pretty well. “Redneck” by contrast referred to an unemployed drunkard who wears dirty sleeveless T-shirts in public and regularly assaults women and puppies.) Anyway, that was a digression and back to Ireland and Northern Ireland. Since I don’t have first-hand experience of these places, I hope my comments below won’t cause any…ire?
- While violence related to the “troubles” mostly ended in 1998, there are occasional marches and confrontations between the Republicans (who tend to be Catholic and favor an independent united Ireland) and Unionists (who tend to be Protestant and favor continued union with the UK.)
- There has been disturbing white-nationalist violence and what can only be described as anti-immigrant pogroms in both Ireland and Northern Ireland in recent years. There have also been large counter-demonstrations. (Interesting that here in the USA white nationalist politician J.D. Vance, who is from my originally Scottish Protestant ethnic group, decided to convert to Catholicism only to be publicly chastised by the Pope himself, who is a famously tolerant guy. But I digress once again.)
- Here are some things I didn’t realize until doing a bit of research: Republic of Ireland citizens can live, work, and travel freely anywhere in the entire EU and anywhere in the entire UK, including Northern Ireland. UK citizens can live, work and travel anywhere in the Republic of Ireland, but they are foreigners in the EU and subject to the same work, travel and visa restrictions as any other foreigners. There are no physical borders or checkpoints between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, and people travel back and forth freely for work similar, I suppose, to how Americans travel between states (which is very common for one thing because major rivers often form the borders between states, major cities often grew up around rivers, and major cities therefore will often straddle two or more states). The south has the stronger economy so more of the work commuting is going to be from north to south. Taxes must get a bit messy for people who do this. Trade gets really messy – UK goods intended only for Ireland have essentially no restrictions, but goods that might end up elsewhere in the EU have all the restrictions the EU would normally have.
